Your Trusted Ratings for Ohio’s Best Golf Courses

Carroll Meadows Golf Course - Carrollton, Ohio

Overall Course Rating

16 / 20

B - Strong Play

Carroll Meadows Golf Course in Carrollton, Ohio, is a charming Northeast Ohio public track that's been a local favorite since opening in 1989.

Designed by John Robinson, this par-71 layout plays to 6,366 yards from the back tees with a course rating of 70.2 and slope of 120. Nestled in scenic Amish Country, it offers rolling fairways, wooded doglegs, and forgiving greens that make it ideal for scrambles or casual rounds. At $25–$45 with cart, it's a budget-friendly gem with solid upkeep and a relaxed vibe. If you're near Canton or Alliance (30–45 minutes drive), it's worth the trip for the value and charm—though expect basic amenities and no frills.

4

Layout / Design

4

Condition

4

Value

4

Amenities

Layout / Design = 4/5
John Robinson's layout emphasizes a serene, flowing design with wide-open fairways framed by farmland views and subtle tree lines.

The front nine eases you in with sweeping par-4s and a few gentle elevation shifts, while the back brings more open spaces and a couple of water-crossing par-3s. It's straightforward and forgiving, prioritizing enjoyment over trickery—ideal for team formats where recovery is key.

No dramatic risk-reward moments, but the natural, pastoral setting adds a unique, countryside vibe.

Scramble teams will appreciate the room for creative plays.
Condition = 4/5
Carroll Meadows maintains excellent turf quality for a public course—greens roll true and fast, fairways are lush and firm, and bunkers are consistently raked.

The premium watered layout holds up well through Ohio's seasons, with vibrant bluegrass and minimal wear even in high-traffic months.

Rough is manageable but thick in spots, and irrigation keeps everything green.
Value = 4/5
At $34 to $44 with cart (18 holes), Carroll Meadows has decent value compared to some other courses in the area.

Weekday Riding (18 holes)
$34
Weekend Riding (18 holes morning)
$44
Weekend Riding (18 holes afternoon)
$34
Amenities = 4/5
The basics are covered: a small pro shop with essentials (balls, tees, apparel), clean restrooms, and a snack bar serving simple fare like burgers ($8–$12).

The course also has the ability to use Simulators when it starts to get that nasty Ohio weather in the fall/winter time.
Playing Experience
Pace runs 4–4.5 hours on this mostly flat, easy-walking course—open fairways invite relaxed swings, but wind across the fields can sneak up.

Greens are average-sized and subtle, easy for lags but tricky for speed control.

For scrambles, the layout encourages fun, low-stress team decisions.
Who It's For
Suits beginners, families, or scramble groups craving a low-key rural escape.

Fits high-handicappers (20+) who want encouragement over punishment. Pass if you seek dramatic features or upscale touches.
Final Thoughts
Carroll Meadows captures simple, satisfying Ohio golf—16/20 for its affordability and serenity. It's not ambitious, but the countryside charm makes it memorable.